Single-use versus Multiple-use Endoscopes in Gastroenterology (SUMU-Endo)

Study Updates

The SUMU-Endo study is a mixed-methods analysis consisting of 5 work packages. The study is taking place over two years and involves systematic reviews, health economics analysis, environmental analysis and qualitative interviews. 

Work package 4 was a qualitative study, recruiting participants from 4 sites in England and Wales. Recruitment has closed as of September 2025.

Our team have been working hard to write up the results for each work package, so far WP2 have published the following papers:

Single-use versus multiple-use accessories in gastrointestinal endoscopy: a systematic review of economic evaluations

Single-use versus reusable endoscopes in gastroenterology: Systematic review of full and partial economic evaluations

Cost of reusable gastrointestinal endoscopes to the NHS: findings from a micro-costing study


All 4 work packages will come together to form work package 5, a comprehensive analysis of infection control, cost effectiveness and environmental impact of single-use vs multiple-use endoscopes.   


For Enquiries:

Tel: 02476 966197
Email: sumuendostudyoffice@uhcw.nhs.uk

Participating Sites

Study Information

Chief Investigator & Team

Chief Investigator: Professor Ramesh Arasaradnam

WP1 Lead: Associate Professor Yen-Fu Chen

WP2 Lead: Dr Lazaros Andronis

WP3 Lead: Dr Stuart Coles

WP4 Lead: Professor Amy Grove

Lead Coordinator: Violet Matthews

Sponsor

University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust

Funder

National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR)

Aim

Primary: To provide evidence for NHS decision makers on the use of single-use vs. multiple-use endoscopes in gastroenterology.

Secondary: To explore how sustainability issues might be considered in future technology assessment by policy-makers such as NICE.

Study Design

Multi-methods analysis

Speciality

Gastroenterology

Summary

WP1: Review of evidence on technical performance, test accuracy and infection risk of single-use vs multiple-use gastrointestinal (GI) endoscopes, and of literature for other work packages.

WP2: Assess costs and consequences arising from use of single-use endoscopes compared to multiple-use ones. We will include specific patient groups (e.g., immunocompromised, those with severe infections) and settings (e.g., intensive care unit) taking into account all factors - costs of purchase, decontamination, consequences of infections etc.

WP3: Assess the wider environmental consequences of a shift to single-use endoscopes including impact on scarce resources for their production and effect of disposal, including landfill and incineration, and the greenhouse gases and waste generated (including transport and storage).

WP4: Explore the views of patients receiving endoscopy and staff involved in using, cleaning and decontaminating endoscopes.

WP5: Provide evidence for patients, health professionals, service commissioners, manufacturers, environmental management and policy makers to make decisions on single-use and multiple-use endoscopes.

Planned Start Date

01 June 2023

WP4: September 2024

Planned Duration

24 months

Target Sample Size

WP4: 60

Results

The results will be published once the study has completed and all data analysed.